In 2025, 51 US boys were named Nicolai, making it the 2,590th most common boys’ name of the year, down 4 places from #2,586 in 2024. That is 1 fewer than the 52 boys named Nicolai in 2024. Its best rank for boys was #1,883, reached in 2015. That year also had the most boys given the name: 78. For comparison, it was #1,883 in 2015 and unranked in 1950.
Social Security card records list Nicolai in 54 years of the 146 from 1880 to 2025, starting in 1962 with 6 babies. In all, 1,865 US babies have been given the name, all of them boys. Its busiest decade was the 2010s, with 607 babies named Nicolai.
Over the 10 years from 2016 to 2025, 554 US boys were named Nicolai; the busiest of those years was 2022, with 69. In 2025 that was about 1 in 33,492 of the boys in SSA’s list for the year.
Among the states, Nicolai ranked highest in Ohio in 2025, at #1,213 for boys there. It was not in the top 100 of any state. Related spellings in the SSA files include Nikolai (11,027 babies since 1880), Nicola (8,090 babies since 1880) and Nikola (4,102 babies since 1880).